You'll never get 'old player names' unless you convince all the old players from your server to come play somewhere
P1999 has old enemies names and nothing past Kunark. They also have hours to level and work hard for everything. Level 60 is the maximum, because level 60 was the maximum with Kunark. So other than the UI and the 'old player names' I really don't understand what you are asking for that p1999 doesn't have to offer.