If you guys are two people posting from the same campus, then I apologize for my original post here. Obviously, more than 1 person can use the same IP, considering families and college campuses or if posting from the same work/company since they would be going through the same router or a proxy. Just kinda seemed like the 2 people were posting like they didn't know each other when obviously they do. Nothing wrong with that though.
And, there are no "tyrant admins populating their own server" onto the preferred server list unless you count Rogean bringing his server up as a Legends (gold color) server once a year or so lol. The issue is that the only people who have access to add preferred servers are not very much (if at all) involved with the project anymore. Otherwise, there are plenty of other good servers out there with large populations, high uptime, and that have been around for more than a year that would be good candidates for a Preferred Server. I know that EZ Server, SoA and my server, Storm Haven all deserve a slot there, and I am sure there are others. IMO, PEQ should be moved to Legends status

If we ever reach a point where current admins involved in the project are able to add servers to the Preferred server list, then we would definitely set certain criteria that would have to be met in order to get on that list. But, that probably isn't going to happen anytime soon.
If Divine Reapers has been around for a year, it does seem a little odd that people waited this long and suddenly multiple people are here posting about it

Sounds like it could be a fun server for people who enjoy that sort of thing.