[Rabayn]

There are some trade skill combines that ( on live at least ) give you back components on a fail. For example, the combine with the Rusty Sylvan Morning Star in this quest:

http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/q...tml?quest=2051

However, on combine both the rusty weapon and sharpening stone are being consumed. Using peq rev 628 I looked in the tradeskill_recipe_entries table and found the recipe:

id    recipe_id   item_id   successcount  failcount  componentcount  iscontainer   
54714 5847        20297     0             1          1               0
54715 5847        12056     0             0          1               0
54716 5847        20300     1             0          0               0
54717 5847        17        0             0          0               1

The sword ( item 20297 above ) has it's failcount set to 1, which to my understanding means on failure it gets returned. But alas, the weapon gets eaten on a failed combine =(. I did confirm this same issue on rev 590 as well. Is my understanding of the failcount wrong and there is no way to return an item on failure or is there something else I need to set or look for?

Thanks for any help you can provide.